-Research Paper-Capital Punishment
Capital Punishment
Capital punishment: The infliction of the death penalty on persons convicted of a crime. As ideas about what crimes should be punishable by death have differed, so have the methods of inflicting this penalty. The criminal has been hanged, burned, boiled in oil, thrown to wild beasts, flayed alive, drowned, crushed, crucified, stoned, impaled, strangled, torn apart, beheaded, smothered, disemboweled, shot, gassed, or electrocuted (Encyclopedia).
Abolition of capital punishment has increased over the last fifty years in worldwide. Fifty-four countries have completely abolished capital punishment, and fifteen nations have abolished it for all except war crimes. Ninety-seven have not carried out any executions for ten years. About two countries abolish capital punishment per year in the world. The United States, however, still practices capital punishment (Mitchell, 2001). Thirty-eight states still allow capital punishment. Twelve states and the District of Columbia have abolished it (State News Service).
Most people agree with the existence of capital punishment, but some people are vehemently against it. The controversy over the death penalty has been ongoing. Capital punishment is in decline now days. Many people might think that there should be no capital punishment, but capital punishment is a just consequence for people who kill others. Even though the methods used in capital punishment seem inhumane, capital punishment should exist in order to control crimes in nations.
In 1608, the first documented execution of an American was recorded. American’s early colonial laws were borrowed from British laws. Under the British law, more than 50 crimes such as vagrancy, heresy, witchcraft, rape, murder, and treason were selected as capital offenses. The US law on capital punishment has changed in some different ways in different states in US. Each states has own law on capital punishment. From 1977 to 1993, the number of prisoners under sentence of death has increased. In 1994, the number reached to 2800 and it was never more than at any time in US history. 250 prisoners are added to sentence of death each year (Mitchell, 2001). For instance, Virginia has executed 94 prisoners since capital punishment was reinstated in 1976. Texas has executed 350 prisoners (Nuckols). More than 70% of Americans are in favor of having some form of capital punishment. Another reason why American is in favor is because of the financial cost of the capital punishment. They believe that capital punishment is cheaper to execute prisoners than to imprison prisoners for the remainder of their natural life in society (Mitchell, 2001).
However, there are myriad reasons why capital punishment has become a huge issue in United States. First familiar opinion is presented by the federal judge Alex Kozinski, a prominent advocate of the death penalty. He states, “I think there’s some idea in this country that if people are evil enough you’re insulting the memory of the victims if you let them live.” An Americans characteristic or culture is that they want to feel and show that they can control evil things (Lifton, 2000). Herbert H. Haines also states about American’s character as a curse on US. He states, “the most important [reason why US cares more about capital punishment than other countries] may be America’s special curse—levels of violent crime so high as to be unique in the industrialized world.” American has been angry and fearful about the crime situation in their country, and capital punishment has become a strong symbol of these situations (Haines, 1996).
There are four common methods of capital punishment. First, hanging was the first method that America used for long years. When the trapdoor opens, the prisoner dropped and they die quickly. It often does not go well. If the drop may be too short, it causes the prisoner dies slowly because of the slow strangulation, or if the drop is too long, the prisoner faces ending in decapitation (Lifton, 2000). A new method of execution was made because people want to make capital punishment even more humane. The new method is called electrocution. In the late 19th century, Thomas Edison explored new uses for electricity. He brought the idea of using electricity to the prison to avoid prisoner escapes from the jail. However, electrocution was thought to be “neater, more scientific, and compassionate.” In the standard procedure of the electrocution, 2,300 volts shocks the prisoner for eight seconds, and then about one third of 2,300 volts shocks the prisoner for another twenty-two seconds. And the procedure ends with five seconds of another 2,300 volts. A veteran witness explained that while it goes through, the smell of burning fills the room and the smell is really bad. Most people thought electrocution was a more humane form of execution than hanging. Only a few states were still using hanging (Lifton, 2000).
In 1924, Major D. A. Turner of the U.S. Army Medical Corps invented another method, gas chamber. Turner thought execution by gas would be even more humane than electrocution. In this execution, in a steel room, the prisoner is tied onto a chair and poisonous gas is filled into the room. Criminal breaths the gas, and after few minutes, the criminal dies. In 1933, California used this method for execution and became the first state used the gas chamber execution (Lifton, 2000).
Later in 1977, another new execution was invented. The name of new execution is lethal injection. During the lethal injection, a doctor gives a shot which has two or three poisonous chemicals in it. First, the chemicals paralyze the criminal’s body, and then few minutes later, the criminal’s heart beating stops and dies. It is a quicker and very easier than hanging, electrocution, or the gas chamber. Texas State began using lethal injection in 1977, and many other states followed to use it. By the year 2000, most states and also many other foreign countries used only lethal injection for executions (Death Penalty Teacher’s Edition.com, Lifton 2000).
Even though the methods of execution developed have become more humane than before, there are still controversies over the capital punishment. Supporters believe that capital punishment was the way to stop the violence. A majority of people in United States believe that the death penalty is the right punishment for the serious crimes such as murder. Capital punishment supporters think “death is fit punishment for the worst crime” (Steffen 1998). Supporters do not see the death penalty as morally wrong. Most supporters argue that murder is cruel and inhumane just like the opinion of opponents’ belief over the capital punishment. Opponents’ major idea is that capital punishment is inhumane and cruel. However, supporters believe that to protect the community, they have to get rid of dangerous criminals by using the capital punishment (Death Penalty Information Center. com, Steffen, 1998).
As supporters exist, there are also opponents of capital punishment. Opponents believe that the capital punishment is cruel and unusual punishment. Their idea comes from the history of United States. For example, slavery and torture was normal in history, but now, it has changed. People consider slavery and torture as cruel and inhumane. Also, governments abolished slavery. However, opponents think that same things should go for the capital punishment. Opponents believe that any kind of killing is wrong, but they do not find differences between capital punishment and killing people. They believe that no one should not take other’s life (Pro-Death Penalty.com, Steffen, 1998).
There is one more major argument against the capital punishment. People think there might be a chance that an innocent person will be executed. In order to avoid this, there are “appeals for the accused to reveal” their innocence (Steffen, 1998). But because human beings judge criminal on justice system, sometimes they make mistakes. A real murderer gets free and an innocent man may get executed. This happens rarely. Steffen explains that, “Now the government is trying hard to search the evidence and find who the criminal really is. Even though there are appeals for the person who is accused of murder, some people think they should take away capital punishment.” Opponents say that methods are one of the reasons why they want to abolish the capital punishment. Electrocution, gas chamber, hanging, or any kinds of methods are too cruel to kill a person. Because of the methods are too cruel, government brought up the new execution, the lethal injection. In this way, a person can die very easy, quickly, and painlessly. But still some people think lethal injection is also cruel. The controversy over the death penalty seems “never-ending” (Death Penalty Information Center. com, Steffen, 1998).
From the beginning there have been arguments over capital punishment. Most of people think that capital punishment is normal and necessary. If capital punishment did not exist, more violent crimes would be committed. Capital punishment is the way to threat and stop people to commit serious crime. As a conclusion, there should be capital punishment in order to deter crime even though the methods of capital punishment are inhumane. If governments take away capital punishment, more people will commit violent crimes. Also, a person who has already committed a crime will be free and the United States become more and more dangerous. Capital punishment should exist in the nation to protect people.
